Is making your own soda better for you?

Direct Answer

There are genuinely two ways to do this: mix a flavoured syrup with carbonated water for a finished soda in about five minutes, or ferment sugar water with yeast over 2-3 days for naturally carbonated, true homebrewed soda. Neither is "more correct" — they're just different projects with different time commitments.

⚡ Ready in Minutes

The Fast Way: Syrup + Carbonated Water

This is exactly how restaurant fountain machines work behind the counter — flavoured syrup mixed with carbonated water on demand, pumped through a lever the moment you press it. At home, you're just doing the same thing manually, with no equipment beyond a saucepan and whatever carbonated water you have on hand.

1

Make a simple syrup: equal parts sugar and water, heated on the stove until fully dissolved, then cooled to room temperature.

2

Infuse it with flavour while still warm — fruit, herbs, ginger, or citrus peel steeped directly in the syrup for at least 20- 30 minutes.

3

Strain out any solids thoroughly, then store the finished syrup in a sealed container in the fridge.

4

Combine a splash of syrup with cold club soda, seltzer, or water from a home carbonator, adjusting the ratio to taste before serving.

Using a home carbonating machine instead of store-bought soda water? Add any acid (like citric acid) to the water before carbonating it, never after — adding granulated ingredients to water that's already carbonated causes it to fizz over almost immediately, which makes a genuine mess of your kitchen counter.

🕐 2-3 Days

The Slow Way: True Fermentation

This is genuine home-brewing — the same basic process as beer, just stopped early. Yeast consumes sugar and produces CO2 as a byproduct, which is what naturally carbonates the bottle rather than a machine forcing gas in.

1

Dissolve sugar in warm water (roughly 2 cups sugar per gallon), then let it cool to 70-80°F.

2

Add your flavouring — fruit juice, extract, or herbs — and a small measured amount of yeast.

3

Bottle immediately and seal tightly, leaving bottles at room temperature.

4

Check carbonation daily by gently squeezing the bottle — once firm, refrigerate immediately.

Genuinely Important

Refrigeration Stops Fermentation — Don't Skip It

Yeast is a living organism, and cold temperatures make it go dormant, which is exactly what halts carbonation at the level you want rather than letting it continue indefinitely. If a bottle is left out of the fridge for an extended period afterward — as little as 6-8 hours in some cases — the yeast can "wake up" and continue fermenting, steadily building pressure inside a fully sealed bottle. Check bottles daily during the initial fermentation window by gently squeezing them, and once they feel genuinely firm rather than soft, refrigerate promptly rather than leaving them out any longer to see what happens next.

Fermentation guidance corroborated via Escoffier Online and established homebrewing practice.

Flavour Ideas Worth Trying

Hibiscus-Lime Ginger & Honey, Strawberry-Basil Butterscotch Cream Mint & Cucumber Spiced Citrus

Read the Full Guide

Are Juice and Soft Drinks the Same Thing? →

Related Reading

Sparkling Water vs Soda Water: What's the Difference? →

Shop Our Soft Drinks Range

Soda water, tonic, and mixers to build your own at home.

Shop Soft Drinks

Frequently Asked Questions

Is homemade fermented soda alcoholic?
At the short fermentation times used for soda, alcohol content stays negligible, since the process is stopped by refrigeration well before yeast would produce meaningful alcohol the way a longer beer fermentation does.
Can I use any type of yeast for homemade soda?
Standard baking or brewing yeast both work, though many home soda makers prefer a small, measured amount of brewing-specific yeast for more predictable, consistent carbonation results.
Why did my homemade soda bottle nearly explode?
This usually means fermentation continued too long before refrigeration, building excess pressure — always check bottles daily and refrigerate as soon as they feel firm to avoid this.
Do I need special bottles for homemade soda?
Bottles genuinely designed to hold pressure, such as swing-top glass bottles or PET plastic soda bottles, are strongly recommended over standard glass jars, which aren't built to safely contain carbonation pressure.
Is the fast syrup method less "real" than fermentation?
Not at all — it's genuinely the same method commercial fountain machines use behind the counter, just done manually at home, so it's a legitimate way to make soda rather than a shortcut version of a "proper" process.

 

Tags:
Back to blog