Which soft drink is best with gin?

Britain's gin scene has grown so dramatically, and so fast, that the old advice of "just add tonic" genuinely doesn't cover it anymore. With hundreds of distinct gin styles now sitting on UK shelves, each built around a different botanical direction, matching the right mixer to the right bottle has become a genuine skill worth learning rather than an afterthought.

The Numbers Behind Britain's "Ginaissance"

This isn't a mild trend that quietly grew over decades — it's genuinely one of the most dramatic growth stories in modern British food and drink history, unfolding within the span of a single working career.

2012 128 distilleries
2015 190 distilleries
2020 560+ distilleries
2026 920+ registered spirit producers

That's more than a sevenfold increase in under fifteen years, from a category that barely registered on the national drinks scene to one that now dominates British spirit shelves. Much of it traces back to Sipsmith opening London's first traditional copper-pot distillery in almost 200 years, widely credited within the industry with kickstarting the modern craft gin movement that dozens of others soon followed into. Interestingly, recent industry analysis suggests overall consumption volumes have begun tapering slightly as the initial novelty naturally settles and younger drinkers shift habits more broadly — but the sheer variety of gin styles now permanently available on UK shelves remains firmly here to stay regardless of that plateau.

Figures drawn from HMRC and Office for National Statistics data, as reported by the Wine and Spirit Trade Association and UK Spirits Alliance.

Match Your Mixer to Your Gin Style

This is genuinely the single most useful thing to understand before reaching for whatever's already in the fridge: different gin styles carry very different botanical profiles depending on how and where they were distilled, and the "correct" mixer depends heavily on which one you happen to be pouring that evening.

Classic

London Dry Gin

Juniper-forward with a firm citrus backbone, the style most people picture when they think of traditional British gin. The quinine bitterness in classic Indian tonic water complements this profile directly rather than competing with it, since both share a similarly assertive character.

Best mixer: Classic Indian tonic
Garnish: Lime or lemon wedge

Contemporary

New Western / Floral Style

Built around cucumber, rose, or other floral and fruit-led botanicals rather than heavy juniper, reflecting much of the newer wave of distilleries. A classic tonic's assertive bitterness can easily overwhelm these subtler, gentler notes rather than complementing them.

Best mixer: Light or elderflower tonic
Garnish: Cucumber ribbon or berries

Worth Trying Beyond Standard Tonic

Ginger Ale

Works particularly well with spiced or citrus-heavy gins, adding genuine warmth and depth rather than the sharp bitterness tonic contributes to the finished drink.

Plain Soda Water

The most genuinely neutral option available, letting a particularly complex or unusual gin's own carefully chosen botanicals take full centre stage without any competing bitterness or sweetness.

Elderflower Tonic

A gentler, noticeably less bitter alternative to classic tonic that suits floral and fruit-forward contemporary gins particularly well, without drowning out their subtler characteristics.

Cucumber Tonic

A specific pairing worth seeking out for cucumber-forward gins, one that reinforces rather than fights against the botanical direction the distiller originally intended.

A Quick Note on Pink Gin

Pink gin deserves its own brief mention, since it's driven a genuinely significant share of the category's recent growth — reportedly accounting for around half of all UK gin growth in one recent year alone. Typically fruit-infused or lightly sweetened during production, pink gin often benefits from a different mixer approach than a traditional London Dry, since it's usually already carrying its own sweetness and fruit character before a single drop of mixer is added.

The Detail Most People Skip

Fill the glass with ice before adding anything else — ice added afterward chills the drink far less effectively overall and dilutes it noticeably faster as it works harder to catch up to the drink's starting temperature. A generally recommended starting ratio is one part gin to two or three parts mixer, adjusted gradually from there according to personal taste and the specific gin's strength, poured gently down the side of the glass rather than straight down the middle to preserve the tonic's carbonation instead of losing most of it to a rough, careless pour.

Shop Our Mixers Range

Tonic, soda, and ginger ale for whatever's in your gin cabinet.

Shop Soft Drinks

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did England overtake Scotland in gin distillery numbers?
This particular shift happened around 2018, largely driven by a wave of new small and micro-distilleries opening across England specifically during that period, while Scotland's distilling identity had traditionally centred far more heavily around whisky production historically rather than gin as its primary spirit category.
Is pink gin a completely different style requiring a different mixer?
Not necessarily an entirely different category on its own, but pink gins are frequently already sweetened or fruit-infused during production, so a classic bitter tonic can sometimes clash noticeably with that existing sweetness — a lighter or fruit-forward tonic frequently works better for balancing the finished drink overall.
Does the type of ice actually make a noticeable difference?
Yes, genuinely — larger ice cubes melt considerably more slowly than crushed ice, meaning less overall dilution across the time it takes to actually finish the drink, which is precisely why larger cubes are generally preferred by bartenders for a longer, more leisurely gin and tonic.
Why has UK gin consumption started levelling off despite so many distilleries?
Industry analysis points to a natural settling after the initial explosive growth of the 2010s finally running its course, combined with broader shifts in overall drinking habits, particularly among younger consumers who are generally drinking less across nearly all alcohol categories, rather than any decline specific to gin itself.
Can I use the same mixer for every gin in my cabinet?
You certainly can, and plenty of people do simply for convenience and simplicity, but matching the mixer more deliberately to each individual gin's specific botanical profile generally produces a noticeably more balanced, considered result, especially once you're working with contemporary or heavily flavoured styles rather than a straightforward London Dry.
Tags:
Back to blog