What is considered a mocktail?

A mocktail is a non-alcoholic drink built using genuine cocktail technique — but the word itself is far older than most people would ever guess, and its most famous example comes with a genuinely surprising twist about how the person it was named after actually felt about it.

What Actually Separates a Mocktail From "Just a Soft Drink"

Not every non-alcoholic drink automatically qualifies for the title. A genuine mocktail generally shares these specific traits with the alcoholic cocktail it's deliberately imitating, rather than simply being any soft drink served in a nicer glass.

Multiple Deliberate Ingredients

Combines several components with genuine intention behind the pairing, rather than being a single flavour poured straight from a can or bottle without any further thought.

Genuine Cocktail Technique

Shaken, stirred, layered, or built with the same care and attention as an alcoholic cocktail, rather than simply mixed and served without ceremony.

Proper Garnish and Presentation

Served in appropriate glassware with a considered garnish, deliberately matching the visual ceremony of whichever cocktail it's standing in for on the menu.

Genuinely Surprising

The Word "Mocktail" Dates Back to 1916

Long before it became a trendy modern term splashed across restaurant menus, "mocktail" was already in genuine documented use, and the underlying concept of a deliberately non-alcoholic cocktail stretches back even further still, with references dating to the 1700s. Before "mocktail" became the standard, widely recognised term, these drinks were also known as "Temperance drinks" or "soft cocktails" — names that directly reflect their close historical association with the broader temperance movement, which actively campaigned against alcohol consumption across both Britain and America for well over a century.

Prohibition Gave the Category Its Biggest Boost

When alcohol became illegal across the United States between 1920 and 1933, bars and restaurants suddenly needed something genuinely appealing and celebratory to fill the obvious gap. Lemonades of every possible description — orangeades, limeades, ginger lemonades, even egg lemonades — became common bar staples almost overnight, and bartenders leaned heavily into fresh herbs, real fruit juice, and creative flavour combinations to keep the experience of drinking out feeling genuinely special without the alcohol that had previously anchored it. Some particularly dedicated bartenders even experimented with tannins, cloves, and other naturally astringent ingredients to recreate the faint "burning" sensation alcohol provides on the palate, showing how seriously this category was taken early on, rather than treated as an afterthought.

The "Original" Mocktail Has a Genuinely Disputed Birth

The Shirley Temple — ginger ale (or lemon-lime soda), a dash of grenadine, and a maraschino cherry — is widely considered the first true mocktail, created in the early 1930s. Its exact origin, though, is a genuine mystery.

Chasen's The Beverly Hills restaurant is most frequently credited, claiming a bartender invented the drink for a young, thirsty Temple.
Brown Derby: The famous Hollywood eatery, which also lays independent claim to the drink's invention.
Royal Hawaiian: Even this Hawaiian hotel has separately claimed its bartenders created the original recipe.

As reported by NPR and Fox News Digital, cocktail historians generally agree the true origin will likely never be definitively settled.

Shirley Temple Herself Actually Hated It

In a 1986 NPR interview, the by-then-grown actress described her own namesake drink as a "saccharine sweet, icky drink" that she genuinely disliked. She was protective of the name too — in 1988, when a company called Soda Pop Kids tried marketing a bottled cherry soda called "Shirley T" without permission, she pursued civil legal action, arguing her name wasn't a generic term free for anyone to use commercially. The drink has clearly outlived any personal feelings about it: in October 2024, 7UP launched a limited-edition "Shirley Temple" flavour, blending lemon-lime with pomegranate and cherry — proof the category she unwittingly started is still evolving nearly a century later.

Shop Our Soft Drinks Range

Everything you need to build your own mocktail at home.

Shop Soft Drinks

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a mocktail just fruit juice with a fancy name?
Not typically — a proper mocktail is usually built from multiple ingredients using genuine cocktail technique and considered presentation, whereas plain fruit juice is a single ingredient served without that same intentional construction, layering, or garnish that defines the category.
Why were mocktails specifically associated with the temperance movement?
The temperance movement actively campaigned against alcohol consumption throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, so these non-alcoholic alternatives were deliberately promoted as a socially acceptable, genuinely celebratory way to drink something special without alcohol, which is exactly why they were once literally called "Temperance drinks" rather than mocktails.
What's actually in the "original" Shirley Temple recipe?
The classic combination is ginger ale or lemon-lime soda, a dash of grenadine syrup for sweetness and its distinctive pink-red colour, and a maraschino cherry garnish on top, though exact proportions and the specific soda used vary considerably depending on who's actually making it.
Is "Dirty Shirley" the same drink with alcohol added?
Yes — a Dirty Shirley is simply the classic Shirley Temple recipe with vodka added on top, essentially reversing the mocktail back into a genuine alcoholic cocktail while deliberately keeping the same familiar flavour profile, colour, and nostalgic presentation intact.
Are mocktails only relevant during Dry January?
Not at all — while Dry January does bring extra seasonal attention to the category each year, mocktails are increasingly ordered year-round by people who simply want a proper, considered drink without alcohol on any given evening, rather than treating it as a once-a-year January exercise.
Tags:
Back to blog